Groupthink and Top Tens

you know. Normally I wouldn't call someone to the table for this because it's rude and what have you but as I was researching my slowly growing online top ten list chart I keep referring to the far more extensive chart at geninn.net and some lists really perplex me.



Take Susan Granger for instance. Her top ten list is:



The Aviator

Collateral

Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

Finding Neverland

Hotel Rwanda

Kinsey

Million Dollar Baby

The Motorcycle Diaries

The Phantom of the Opera

Ray



Can it get any more generic? It's the exact same as the [b]BFCA[/b] list with ONE exception -the absence of Sideways and inclusion of The Motorcycle Diaries. Granger is a free thinker ! (hee) Sometimes I wonder if there are too many voices out there and if the collective "best of" thing is just too disturbing. I much prefer lists that show some semblance of sanity (obviously Eternal Sunshine belongs on every list) combined with the individual's own unique aesthetic sense. If you have no opinion of your own --what's the point? For the record my own personal top ten will have some of the usual suspects. But as always, I hope to maintain my own voice.



I'm not trying to knock Susan Granger or praise myself. I'm more thinking out loud about the problem of homogeny in these things. I know why this happens. I am affected by it myself. Would I have watched Sideways a second time were it not for the abundant "best of the year" kudos which made me revisit it and boosted it from "very good" in my book to "near great" It would probably have made my top ten list either way but its placement did rise. Critical consensus does affect people for good (Sideways) and ill (Million Dollar Baby for instance. Good film...but critical consensus has it as a masterpiece and it just ain't so).



I wonder how less generic things would be if we were all required to make our top ten lists on the same day of the year? How cool would it be to have a year when all major awards nominations take place on the very same day with none influencing the next? Where would the Oscars, for instance, go without the guidance from the guilds, the Globes, and critics?



If you look at the geninn.net's current top ten list you'll find the following films appearing on the most top ten lists:



01 SIDEWAYS 102 lists with 30 #1 placements

02 ETERNAL SUNSHINE OF THE SPOTLESS MIND on 91 lists with 17 #1s

03 BEFORE SUNSET 75/14

04 MILLION DOLLAR BABY 63/12

05 THE AVIATOR 53/4

06 THE INCREDIBLES 53/2

07 KILL BILL, VOL.2 48/1

08 KINSEY 40/2

09 BAD EDUCATION 39/4

10 HOUSE OF FLYING DAGGERS 37/6



Half of those are also on my top ten list. shrug