I saw a test screening of that Cormac McCarthy adaptation
The Road last night. I shan't review since it's not a completed film yet (described as "work in progress") and you can't judge something still under construction. Well, you
can but it's unwise. So much will change. Unless they really are trying to reach a 2008 release in which case -- well, I hope they go ahead and just
move it to 2009 and give it the fine tuning it deserves. Maybe make it a Spring release. The rule that movies for thinking adults can only open September through December is making the cinema as barren 3/4ths of the year as the landscapes in
The Road.Viggo and Kodi. What are you looking at?
So... work in progress. Fine tuning can help anything: Trim this scene, delete that redundant one. But I worry. They passed out those infamous test-screen questionnaires and delicate art fare like this... Well, won't it just get stupid missing-the-point notes like "TOO DEPRESSING!"? Or "but
why was there an apocalypse???" I hope they incinerate clueless scribbles and concentrate on constructive ones.
The movie is very faithful to McCarthy's novel in current shape. It has mostly the same story beats as The Man and the Boy travel south trying to avoid starvation, cannibals, and unforgiving weather.
The Road wisely avoids narration (the novel is minimalist and voice-over would conjure the opposite feeling altogether) and the production design from the
Children of Men team is believably ashen and lived-in: They've cornered the market on post-apocalyptic drama! The Man (
Viggo Mortensen) and The Boy (
Kodi Smit-McPhee) have super chemistry which is a huge relief since everything potent about the story requires it. All of the nomadic starving ensemble have tiny roles but
Robert Duvall floored me and
Garret Dillahunt (rapidly turning into one of my favorite character actors) spooked me, respectively.
I'm crossing my fingers that the final touches make it sharper and more potent (and a lot will depend on color, light and editing --it wasn't a finished print) but it's good.
*breathes sigh of relief**